Twitter and Plurk, Announcements and Conversations
It was passably odd this morning to bring up Twitter in Twhirl and find a quotation from myself. My zine co-editor says that I am the most quotable person that she has ever met, but I think she is just being nice to me. There is very little evidence to support her claim. I will be ever indebted to mwiegand for finally proving that my co-editor might have a point. ;o) The quote I found on Twitter this morning was one that I made up several days ago, in trying to distill the essence of the difference between Plurk and Twitter. Here’s a screen grab from Twitter:
I look upon this as the truth, revealed. When you bring up Twitter, natively or in a client, what you see is a vertical series of announcements by a group of people, i.e. those whom you follow. Those announcements are more or less unconnected to each other visually, except in those rare cases when two or more people happen to be Tweeting at exactly the same time.
Generally, any response is separated from any announcement by many vertical units of measure, and considerable time. Because of this, there tend to be a lot of announcements and very few responses. This makes the interface, and thus the service itself, feel somewhat stiff and formal, as if a town crier were reading announcements in the town square.
When you bring up Plurk, you see a long series of threads. Each thread is a conversation, of one sort of another, spread out along a seemingly infinite visual timeline. Some are like parlor games, some are highly intellectual, some have business aspects, but most are simply fun, an exchange of information among friends. You can time-travel along the timeline, picking from many conversations, seeing what others have said and having your say.
This, of course, makes Plurk seem free, open, and informal. It is very much like being at a party, teeming with people that you know to one level or another, and being able to talk with them (or not) on a selective basis. You can participate in some conversations and ignore others, even making somes disappear if you want to. Likewise, you can choose who to listen to, and which conversations you participate in, and can even make specific people disappear.
All of this results in almost complete social freedom. The level of interaction at Plurk is extremely high. Uttering the equivalent of hundreds of sentences per day is not at all odd. Actual personal things get said on Plurk, and actual personal responses are uttered and listened to, all at a time of your choosing. If you get there late, you can catch up, and still participate. At Plurk, time waits for every man.
I am KDFrawg on Plurk. If you see me, say something meaningful to me.






June 21st, 2008 at 11:31 am
I suspect even your quotes have quotes!
“If you get there late, you can catch up, and still participate. At Plurk, time waits for every man.”
June 21st, 2008 at 11:36 am
@Sara -
Well, to be fair, the good part of that quote was sort of a re-Plurk of Sir Walter Scott.
KDFrawg (The Plurkiverse dewd)
June 21st, 2008 at 12:32 pm
Thinks that plurk is taking over many peoples lives with the conversation aspect, I mean look at me, I was a nobody on Twitter =D . If you have skype KDFrwg I really need to discuss something w/ you. Hit me up because Private Plurks are down atm!
June 21st, 2008 at 12:33 pm
Hmmm. Now that I think of it, you are totally right. I always knew that twitter was a really bummer for conversations. Always on top of it, you are!
June 21st, 2008 at 12:48 pm
I will converse with iron-witted fool.
June 21st, 2008 at 2:55 pm
I completely agree with Thoughtwrong. I used to use twitter. But I never really liked it. And I never felt a sense of community there. It was just a bunch of people announcing things, just like you put it best KDFrawg, with me never really wanting to announce anything. I was always much more of a responder, but it was so clunky and ugly to try and track a conversation between people.
Now, in Plurk, I’ve got a pretty good group of friends I’ve never met in real life but am sure I’d love to, and people who say “Hey! There you are!” when I don’t show up for a day or so… It’s awesome
You hit the nail on the head with that one, KDFrawg
June 21st, 2008 at 4:03 pm
She agrees with @thoughtwrong and @KeithHanson. She really never got the hang of Twitter and she now has great friends she really enjoys plurking with, including frawggy, @thoughtwrong and @KeithHanson.
Yes, she’s aware that she’s typing in third person.
June 21st, 2008 at 4:10 pm
All you have to do is look at these comments to see why Plurk rocks. What an incredible bunch of smart, thoughtful, nice people, all in one place! Plurk is awesome, Plurkers are awesome, and I feel WAY lucky!
KDFrawg (the Plirkiverse dewd)
June 21st, 2008 at 4:32 pm
I love that “at Plurk, time waits for every man”. I think you also said in one of your other posts, “Plurk has the Cheer’s mentality” meaning you feel as if your are known and appreciated by the community.
June 21st, 2008 at 5:23 pm
Have to agree. I to was a small timer on Twitter. Lots of friend but few friendships. But I think I talk to at least 15 different people on Plurk every day. And they talk back. Feels like the start of the IM days to me.
June 21st, 2008 at 6:05 pm
@tony - Thanks a million for stopping by! You are exactly right. It was easy to get followers on Twitter, but that was not what I wanted, either. Like you, I see people every day on Plurk that I am just way happy to talk with. Plurk is my kind of place!
@Chihuatude - I didn’t say “Plurk has the Cheers mentality” but I wish I would have. Plurk does!
KDFrawg (the Plurkiverse dewd)
June 21st, 2008 at 9:13 pm
Notwithstanding that I have under 14 days of experience with Plurk, I’ve discovered in that short time, that I completely agree with you @kdfrawg. I have an immediate sense of connecting to others with Plurk, and that’s what you’ve hit on by describing it as “When you bring up Plurk, you see a long series of threads. Each thread is a conversation, of one sort of another, spread out along a seemingly infinite visual timeline.”
The threaded quality of the conversation(s)is more like that of following topics in forums, but with the added improvement of the timeline…which is pretty unique. You’ve also made distinctions of the types of conversations, i.e. “parlor games, …highly intellectual, …business aspects, …simply fun, an exchange of information among friends.” and this is also the major appeal for me.
Using the timeline to jump back and forth, and keep up with multiple simultaneous conversations, is what keeps it exciting. It must also be why Plurk is a fresh reminder of what Social software was like way back when it started, & people with similar likes and dislikes were finding each other for the first time, e.g. tribe.net.
So when you refer to how “Actual personal things get said on Plurk, and actual personal responses are uttered and listened to, all at a time of your choosing.” … well, you’re talking about having real conversations with real people. Welcome back, my friends.
June 21st, 2008 at 10:03 pm
@phoenixbird -
That was all beautifully said. There are so many reasons why this place rocks, but a lot of is is back to the basics with a killer GUI. Good call, and thanks for the time it took to share that with us!
KDFrawg (the Plurkiverse dewd)
July 5th, 2008 at 11:22 pm
I agree with your article and would only add that to myself, Plurk seems to be an IM (yahoo, MSN, AOL) flattened out without tabs or multiple windows. Laid out in a way that makes it all easy to digest and skim through.